Cash for Clunkers: A Clunker of a Program
Upon first hearing about the ‘Cash for Clunkers’ government program I thought it sounded like a deal. It also sounded like the perfect time for this broke college student to trade in her 2000 Kia Spectra for something new and shiny. Having only paid $1500 for this car myself I figured I would never get someone to pay as much money for my car than what the government was just handing over. It’s not like my little green nine-year old car is in bad shape. Sure it has a scratch here and there and a small dent the side; it still has manual locks and roll-up windows. But it ran, it only has 55,000 miles on it, and it gets me from point A to point B. I figured I didn’t need to add anymore onto my debt and kept my clunker, and I think I made the right decision.
The Car Allowance Rebate System more commonly known as ‘Cash for Clunkers’ seemed like a beneficial program on the outside. The program started on July 1, 2009 and ended on August 24 of the same year. The reason for the sooner- than-expected ending date was due to the end of its resources, which ended up being three billion US dollars. The program consisted of trading in old cars for a bonus of up to $4,500 of taxpayer money for the purchase of a lease of one of the eligible cars under the program. The purpose of ‘Cash for Clunkers’ was to help car dealers bring in customers in hopes they would buy off the surplus supply of vehicles. In the first month it looked like the program was a huge success because of the very high demand. The aftermath of the program proved that it provided more harm than good.
For consumers this program could have been the best or the worst depending on one’s situation. Those people looking to buy a new car benefitted greatly but only if they could afford the vehicle in the first place. They basically received a huge discount on a new car, which they would have been willing to pay full price for in upcoming months or years anyway. Even though to these new car owners the new program was like a gift, it was a misfortune to the taxpayers who are financing the program and ultimately the other patron’s new vehicles.
On the other hand, middle and lower class individuals in need of a vehicle but who could not afford a new car did not make out so well. The worst part is that now because of the program many customers can not even find a used car. Part of the deal of the Car Allowance Rebate System was that the old cars that were traded in had to be destroyed. Even cars that like mine, that still only had 55,000 miles and ran perfectly were being crushed. Some cars could have been only a year old! These are valuable resources being demolished when they could be useful to other consumers, therefore these cars should have been used for their own program in which they sell these cars not destroy them. Instead, the prices of used cars have gone up in response to the reduced supply making it hard for some to purchase a vehicle.
Meanwhile from the economic standpoint the program was more costly than beneficial. According to two University of Delaware professors, Burton Abrams and George R. Parsons, the total cost per car was about 2,000 dollars! What was just supposed to be a one billion dollar program ended up being three billion dollars paid out to the purchases of 700,000 cars. Although the short term effects were good and the program ended up reaching its goal on what it intended to do, which was to reduce the surplus supply of vehicles, it was not cost beneficial. There are also no long term effects. The auto industry sales have slumped back down to what they were before the program took place. The program also may have declined sales for the upcoming quarter because instead of waiting to buy cars people jumped right on board of the program. Furthermore, many auto dealers haven’t received all their vouchers owed to them by the government.
Overall the Car Allowance Rebate System had more cons than pros. It didn’t boost car sales for the year at all. It wasn’t cost beneficial and it also hurt the most susceptible people in the current recession based economy, the lower and middle class. It is safe to say that I am glad that I did not send my ‘Specy’ to its death.
About the Author
9 (2009) Movie Trailer – Tim Burton
|
|
Jeff Burton #1 NASCAR DOLLAR BILL UNCIRCULATED MINT US CURRENCY CASH $9.81 |
|
|
Jeff Burton #2 NASCAR DOLLAR BILL UNCIRCULATED MINT US CURRENCY CASH $9.81 |
|
|
Antique Horatio Alger Book Lot of 3 1800’s – 1900’s DJ HB Bob Burton Cash Boy… $9.99 |
|
|
Two books by Horatio Alger, Jr.-Cash Boy & Bob Burton Dust Jackets $19.99 |
|
|
Set of 4 Apple shaped red ceramic CANISTERS country kitchen home decor NEW $44.00 Four ceramic canisters that will be the perfect decorative touch as well as a useful tool in your kitchen. Goes great with an apple or fruit theme. Detailed Hand-painting. The canisters measure approx: X-Large Jar With Cover: 9.88″ H x 7.75″ W |
|
|
Wooden Crate Picnic UTENSIL Holder outdoor kitchen Bring this rustic handy utensil holder along with you to stock up for your afternoon picnic. Each crate is made of beautiful dark wood and contains 4 wooden boxes to keep all your utensils separate. The crate also has a comfortable carrying handle and sits low to the ground, so it won’t tip over easily. What a great addition to your picnic gear. Each crate measures 10″x9″x3″. Each smaller box me… |
|
|
Ellis Island $5.85 The Irish Tenors’ fourth album sees the trio of Anthony Kearns, Ronan Tynan, and Finbar Wright paying a sentimental musical tribute to Ellis Island, the hallowed landmark that met the majority of immigrants entering the United States at the beginning of the 20th century. Needless to say, the Tenors’ repertoire this time around is full of reflective ballads of love, loss, and homesickness, includin… |
|
|
Johnny 99 $75.99 THIS IS A VINYL RECORD ALBUM BY JOHNNY CASH CALLED “JOHNNY 99″, & IT’S ON THE COLUMBIA LABEL #FC-38696 IN STEREO, & CAME OUT IN 1983. IT WAS HIS 99th LP ON COLUMBIA LABEL & CONTAINS (10) C&W TUNES LIKE: “HIGHWAY PATROLMAN, THAT’S THE TRUTH, GOD BLESS ROBERT E. LEE, NEW CUT ROAD, JOHNNY 99, BALLAD OF THE ARK, JOSHUA GONE BARBADOS, GIRL FROM THE CANYON, BRAND NEW DANCE + I’M RAGGED BUT I’M RIGHT”. *… |
|
|
Today’s Golden Hits; Tomorrow’s golden Memories; 8x Vinyl LP Boxed Set … |
|
|
In the Spirit [VHS] $14.98 … |
|
|
Guyana Tragedy: The Story of Jim Jones [VHS] $11.99 … |
|
|
Murder Story [VHS] … |
|
|
Mars Attacks! $3.49 It’s enlightening to view Tim Burton’s Mars Attacks! as his twisted satire of the blockbuster film Independence Day, which was released earlier the same year, although the movies were in production simultaneously. Burton’s eye-popping, schlock tribute to 1950s UFO movies actually plays better on video than it did in theaters. The idea of invading aliens ray gunning the big-name movie stars in the … |
|
|
Ali $4.70 Ali is a rush of charm, violence, and well-crafted mythmaking sure to enthrall. From the unforgettable surge of the opening–a 10-minute montage of sheer brilliance where formative scenes from the early life of Cassius Clay float along on the rapture of a live performance by Sam Cooke in a Harlem nightclub–through to Muhammad Ali’s departure for Zaire to fight George Foreman, Michael Mann’s homag… |
