Barefoot Training vs Shoes
Mel Siff at health.groups.yahoo.com/group/Supertraining/ gives his thoughts on the trend of barefoot training vs shoes – compelling reading!
In view of all the comments on the use of shoes in sport, here are some
extracts from our “Supertraining” book (Siff & Verkhoshansky 1999 Ch 
that
are relevant to the discussion.
Later I have provided a collection of websites that will also shed some more
light on this issue.
SHOES AND SAFETY
Shoe manufacturers would have athletes believe that the primary solution to
most athletic injuries is the wearing of expensive footwear. Ailments such as
shin splints, iliotibial band syndrome and peripatellar pain are attributed
variously to excessive shock loading of the limbs, pronation or supination.
Research, however, reveals that fewer injuries occur among those who wear
thin soled shoes and that current athletic footwear may even be injurious
(Robbins et al, 1988). The paradoxical observation of a much lower incidence
of running injuries reported in barefoot populations implies that modern
running shoes may produce injuries that normally would not occur without
their use (Robbins & Hanna, 1987). Furthermore, running shoes seem to be
associated with fewer injuries in fitness classes than so-called ‘aerobics
shoes’. Nigg (1986) reports that, on firm shock absorbing mats, the
difference in heel strike force is minimal between bare feet, thick-soled
shoes and thin-soled shoes. Nigg also points out that the use of any shoe
usually increases the tendency of the foot to pronate, particularly if the
impact forces are smaller.
Moreover, several studies have shown that there is no correlation between the
amount of shoe cushioning and impact absorption by footwear during locomotion
(Robbins et al, 1988; Clarke et al, 1982). Similarly, epidemiological
studies have failed to provide evidence that expensive modern athletic
footwear enhances protection from injury to the lower extremities (Caspersen
et al, 1984; Powell et al, 1986). Thus, it would appear that safety of the
lower extremity is not simply a consequence of suitable footwear, but of
learning how to move the body efficiently while wearing a specific type of
shoe.
SHOE DESIGN
Clearly, the science of athletic shoe design is far from being exact. For inst
ance, the current fo-cus is on foot pronation. Other possible causes of
injury such as toe, ankle, knee and hip movement in three dimensions are
largely neglected. Moreover, footwear design is based almost exclusively on
theoretical models which postulate that shock loading and the inability of
the human anatomy to adapt to this loading are the primary causes of running
injuries. This becomes evident from the claims of manufacturers that their
specific shoes correct excessive pronation, control the rearfoot, offer
superior arch support or absorb shock effectively. These shoes do not modify
the impact forces during locomotion, a fact which casts severe doubt on the
cushioning philosophy that forms the foundation of all current shoe design.
Studies by Robbins et al (1988) have shown that the sole of the bare foot
exhibits a powerful plantar surface protective response which diminishes
plantar loading on ground contact, thereby reducing the risk of damage from
overloading during locomotion. Their work also revealed that this response
was not apparent among subjects who always wear shoes, especially the highly
shock-absorbing shoes generally worn by runners. They concluded this
protective response prevents injury by decreasing system rigidity, thereby
diminishing the peak force during foot impact. The lack of the protective
response among shoe wearers apparently is due to diminished plantar sensory
feedback, possibly combined with mechanical interference with arch deflection
by shoe laces, heel counters and arch supports (Robbins et al, 1988). It
would seem that sufficient regular locomotor activity without footwear should
be done daily to maintain the sensitivity of the plantar protective reflex
and that less emphasis should be concentrated on designing passive
shock-absorbing or pronation-modifying shoes.
Little work has been done on relating lower limb injury to anthropometric
factors such as bodymass, height or limb length, or other factors including
level of qualification, movement intensity, muscle fibre distribution,
patterns of EMG activity, feedback processes or bone density. No research
has examined aerobics or ‘cross training’ shoes with this degree of
thoroughness, nor has it carried out entirely satisfactory three-dimensional
studies of all physical factors influencing the efficiency of whole body
movement from initiation to termination of a locomotor action, in particular
with respect to the optimal design of any shoe.
Irrespective of how well designed shoes are, they must be used correctly in
different move-ments. In doing so the user must be aware that shoes always
reduce the proprioceptive and tactile sensitivity to the surface on which
they are being used.
Another reflex is also worthy of attention. Forces exerted on the shoe are
delayed in being transmitted through its shock absorbing sole en route to the
foot. The reflex positive supporting reaction (see 3.5.3), which normally
operates highly effi-ciently in bare feet to produce strong reflex extension
of the legs and stabilisation of the body, is delayed in facilitating rapid
cybernetic control and correction of unsafe movements when shoes are worn.
In particular, the locus of application of pres-sure to the surface of the
sole of the foot determines the position to which the limb will extend
(Guyton, 1984), so that inappropriate geometry of the shoe can significantly
alter the pattern of recruitment of the muscles of the lower extremities.
In contrast, the use of bare feet on firm, very high density chip-foam mats
in the average fitness class preserves proprioceptive efficiency, lowers the
centre of gravity of the body and, unlike shoes, does not increase the lever
arm length from the point of heel contact to the ankle joint, thereby
reducing the moments of force about all joints of the lower limb.
If anyone is interested in the biomechanics of shoe design and use, the
following book is very informative:
Nigg, B The Biomechanics of Running Shoes 1986
There are several useful websites on gait analysis and footwear that are also
relevant. Here is a small sample of ones that you might enjoy:
barefooters.org/medicine/med_sci_sports_exer-23.2.html (Barefoot
Running)
barefooters.org/medicine/ (Bare feet are healthier)
uni-essen.de/~qpd800/FWISB/sneakers.html (Footwear Biomechanics)
ortho.rush.edu/gait/cases1.htm (Gait Analysis – Educational site)
polyu.edu.hk:80/cga/ (Clinical Gait Analysis)
About the Author
Mel Siff
Author of Supertraining
Author of Facts and Fallacies of Fitness
www.melsiff.com
Strength Shoe, Increase Vertical Leap, Run Faster, Jump Higher with Strength Training Shoes
|
|
PUMA TX-301 CROSS TRAINING SHOES 18424705 GREY MEN 12 $0.01 |
|
|
Women’s Nike Air size 7.5 white Training shoes $0.99 |
|
|
THOMAS THE TRAIN BOYS BLUE SLIPPERS HOUSE SHOES SIZE M 7 8 THOMAS BLUE EUC $0.99 |
|
|
MENS~STRENGTH~SHOES~SZ 12~BASKETBALL~JUMPING~MUSCLE BUILDING~TRAINING $0.99 |
|
|
MENS ADIDAS MESH TRAIN LO TOPS CROSS TRAINING SNEAKERS SHOES GREY YELLOW SIZE 12 $0.99 |
|
|
WOMEN REEBOX RUNNING CROSS TRAINING SHOES SIZE 7 USA 4.E UK $0.99 |
|
|
Golf Shoe Part Spike Easy Replace Change Cleat Sport Training Aid $0.99 |
|
|
Belly Dance Dancing Training Women Ladies Dancer Shoes Soft Heel + Bag Silvery $0.99 |
|
|
Belly Dance Women Dancer Danceing Training Shoes Soft Heel + Bag 24cm 9.44″ long $0.99 |
|
|
NEW Robeez Baby Infant Crib Shoes Soft Soled 0-6 months Newborn Train Caboose $0.99 |
|
|
NEW AUTHENTIC NIKE JORDAN TRUNNER II LX MEN’S TRAINING SHOE US 10 $0.99 |
|
|
Nike Nylon Track and Field Training Shoe Spike Shoe Bag $0.99 |
|
|
KATAPULT ATI Training Shoes—Men’s 10.5—Great Condition $0.99 |
|
|
MOOSPO TAEKWONDO shoes competition training US8.5 Size TKD Tae kwon Do Canvas $0.99 |
|
|
New Cleatskins Golf Shoes Bag Black Cleats Socks Towel Putter Training Aid Sun $0.99 |
|
|
MENS~NIKE AIR~PEGASUS~SHOES~SZ 8~RUNNING~TRAINING $0.99 |
|
|
MENS~NIKE SHOX~SHOES~SZ 8.5~RUNNING~TRAINING~GRAY&GREEN $0.99 |
|
|
WOMENS~NIKE DART 7~SHOES~SZ 8~BROWN&TEAL~RUNNING~TRAINING $0.99 |
|
|
2012 Sample ADIDAS Training 180 BOUNCE Running Shoe Trainer 360 TL3 Women’s 7 $0.99 |
|
|
shoeszoo carozoo train black 12-18m soft sole leather baby shoes slippers $0.99 |
|
|
Nike Air Max TR Mens Athletic shoe trainer training black running size 12 Sports $0.99 |
|
|
1940s Hood Rubber Boots Shoes Train Track Art Ad $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
New CARS THOMAS TANK ENGINE TRAIN Boys’ Shoe Charms $0.99 |
|
|
NEW BALANCE 623 Women’s Cross Training Running Shoes Women’s Size 6 $1.00 |
|
|
Strength basketball training shoes mens size 8 $1.00 |
|
|
2012 Women’s ASICS GT-2170 BLACK Running/Training Shoes – Size 8.5 – $130+ T256N $1.00 |
|
|
2012 Women’s ASICS GEL-1170 Running/Training Shoes – Size 9.5 – $130+ T1P5N $1.00 |
|
|
Nike tennis shoes cross trainer air size 9 1/2 men training $1.00 |
|
|
The Pointe Book: Shoes, Training and Technique $1.00 |
|
|
Instablend Personal Blender…to Insta-blend Just Press & Twist! INSTABLEND SAVES YOU TIME in the kitchen so you can SPEND MORE TIME ENJOYING THE LIFE YOU WANT! Perfect for the cook at home, executive on the run, offices, health clubs & college students! INSTABLEND is the MOST DEPENDABLE, HIGHEST QUALITY Personal SINGLE SERVING Blender on the market today! Whether youre on a meal replacement diet, bodybuilding regiment, or want QUICK natural fresh homemade meal… |
|
|
Workout Photo Mugs Workout. Legs of a woman using exercise steps….. |
|
|
Workout Photo Mugs Workout. Feet of a woman using exercise steps….. |
|
|
Jean Butler’s Irish Dance Master Class $11.05 An original star of Riverdance takes Irish dancing to a new level, in lessons suitable for beginners and accomplished dancers alike. Butler’s instruction features techniques and exercises not only for use in the home or classroom to learn dance methods; you can also create and program your own personal routines as a fun way to keep fit. 100 min. Soundtrack: English; behind-the-scenes footage…. |
|
|
Merrell Men’s Moab Ventilator Hiking Shoe Walnut Size 9.5 $84.40 Roam with adventurous intent in the Merrell Moab Ventilator Mens multi-sport shoe. This men’s shoe features a breathable mesh lining that keeps the foot in contact withcooling air. Heel and toe bumpers provide encompassing protection fromtreacherous terrain. An Air Cushion in the midsole meets the sole withstability and shock absorption. The Vibram rubber outsole delivers adurable tread pattern fo… |
|
|
Merrell Men’s Moab Ventilator Hiking Shoe Walnut Size 10.5 $84.95 Roam with adventurous intent in the Merrell Moab Ventilator Mens multi-sport shoe. This men’s shoe features a breathable mesh lining that keeps the foot in contact withcooling air. Heel and toe bumpers provide encompassing protection fromtreacherous terrain. An Air Cushion in the midsole meets the sole withstability and shock absorption. The Vibram rubber outsole delivers adurable tread pattern fo… |
|
|
The T&N Files (Tooth and Nail Video Compilation Vol. 4) $23.95 … |
|
|
The T&N Files Tooth & Nail Vol. 4 $2.98 … |
|
|
KleenKover Carpet Film Temporary Carpet Protection 24 X 200′ Reverse Wind $34.95 Carpet Film Temporary Carpet Protection 24″ X 200′ Reverse Wound for easy application. Protects Synthetic Carpet During Renovation Or New Construction. Also great for Model Homes, Moving, Parties, Kennel Club Shows and Inclement Weather. 3 mil thick. Reverse Wound…. |
|
|
Saucony Women’s ‘ProGrid Guide 4′ Technical Running Shoes $46.99 The ‘ProGrid Guide 4′ is the perfect everyday training shoe. Ideal for light stability runners, the Guide 4 offers a dual density midsole for motion control and support throughout the entire gait cycle. |
|
|
Brooks Men’s ‘Trailblade’ Grey Cross Training Athletic Shoes $45.99 The Trailblade cross training shoes from Brooks highlight a light and durable fabric upper construction. These athletic shoes also feature an abiding rubber outsole, and a forgiving footbed. |
|
|
Saucony Women’s ‘ProGrid Guide 4′ Technical Running Shoes $54.99 The ‘ProGrid Guide 4′ is the perfect everyday training shoe. Ideal for light stability runners, the Guide 4 offers a dual density midsole for motion control and support throughout the entire gait cycle. |
|
|
Skechers Women’s ‘Pro TR’ Blue Training/ Fitness Shoes $43.49 The fabulous blue and purple training shoes from Skechers allow you to enhance your fitness routine. SmartShoe design, lateral protection, and a kinetic return system all ensure ensure maximum work-out efficiency. |
|
|
Saucony Men’s ‘Progrid Guide 4′ Running Shoes $60.99 The Saucony ProGrid Guide 4 is the perfect everyday training shoe. Ideal for light stability runners, the Guide 4 offers a dual density midsole for motion control and support throughout the entire gait cycle, ensuring a great run every time. |
